ProBeat: The TikTok acquisition isn’t going to occur

Once I wrote in regards to the pressured TikTok acquisition final month, I spelled out what everybody needs. The Trump administration needs hassle for TikTok (and China), Microsoft needs TikTok’s knowledge (and algorithm), and dad or mum firm ByteDance needs to be in command of its personal future (and revenues). Oracle has since waded in as a possible acquirer (which makes even much less sense than Microsoft as the customer) and China is beginning to throw its weight round. Loads has occurred, and but we’re no nearer to a decision earlier than U.S. President Donald Trump’s September 15 sell-by deadline. A month in the past, I didn’t assume Microsoft would purchase TikTok. Now I don’t assume we’ll see a TikTok acquisition in any respect.

I’m not saying this as a result of CNBC reported a deal could be introduced final week after which nothing occurred. Nor am I studying an excessive amount of into this week’s stories: The Wall Avenue Journal says ByteDance is speaking with the Trump administration about avoiding a sale of its U.S. TikTok operations, whereas Bloomberg says ByteDance might be going to overlook the deadline.

To me, all of those stories merely point out that the explanations towards a deal preserve mounting. In the meantime, the arguments for a deal have been by no means there to start with — they have been artificially imposed. Placing apart the truth that forcing overseas companies to promote their most prized possession is inherently problematic, listed below are the obstacles discouraging a TikTok acquisition.


This entire brouhaha started when Trump gave Microsoft 45 days to seal a TikTok deal. That’s an insufficient period of time for any U.S. firm to drag off an acquisition that was by no means on the desk of their wildest desires, not to mention one as difficult as that of a social app owned by a Chinese language firm with customers all over the world. Such strain definitely will get potential events speaking, however it additionally makes them much less more likely to deal with all of the soiled particulars that in regular circumstances take months to hammer out.

Subsequent, Trump needs a minimize of TikTok’s sale worth. Ignoring the harmful precedent such a requirement units, whose pocket is that slice going to return out of? Neither social gathering has motive to pay what quantities to “key cash” — in Trump’s personal phrases — an unlawful actual property finder’s charge. The demand solely makes a deal much less interesting.


Including extra friction, TikTok is suing the Trump administration over his government order that bans U.S. transactions with TikTok beginning on September 20. What’s going to the courts say about that — and can they are saying it within the subsequent week? If the courts don’t make a transfer, TikTok clones which can be stealing its customers will quickly be stealing its U.S. revenues, making the app even much less enticing to potential patrons.

Complicating issues additional, all of the acquisition talks have been targeted on TikTok’s North American, Australian, and New Zealand operations. Meaning a possible acquirer isn’t getting the entire app, nor all its customers and knowledge. TikTok wouldn’t simply be separated from ByteDance, but in addition from TikTok’s different areas, including to the lengthy record of technical challenges such a deal would entail.

Talking of which, no person can articulate precisely how TikTok’s knowledge could be moved from ByteDance to a brand new dad or mum firm. TikTok applies machine studying to that knowledge to find out which movies you might be most probably to interact with, so it could actually serve you extra related content material or content material that individuals with related preferences like. Nevertheless it’s not clear whether or not TikTok’s AI algorithm — the true worth of a possible deal — would come alongside for the trip.


Not coincidentally, China added AI tech to its export management record late final month, together with “customized content material suggestions primarily based on knowledge evaluation.” Translation: TikTok’s AI algorithm isn’t on the market. In case the message didn’t hit residence, China’s state media quoted a authorities advisor saying ByteDance ought to examine the brand new export record and “significantly and cautiously” take into account halting deal negotiations. That is simply one other battle within the AI arms race, wherein the U.S. is forward and China is closing in.

The U.S. has a problematic deadline and finder’s charge, the lawsuit and technical challenges aren’t serving to, and China needs to disclaim any type of acquisition that entails TikTok’s most useful asset.

Moreover, China’s President Xi Jinping can and can play the lengthy sport. Whereas Trump is constrained by a pesky downside referred to as the U.S. Structure (Modification XXII limits the workplace of the president to 2 phrases), Jinping abolished presidential time period limits in 2018.

I, like everybody else, do not know what’s going to in the end occur. Trump may save face by asserting {that a} deal has been reached, with no follow-up forthcoming. (He’s definitely made tech bulletins that weren’t his to make earlier than.) Or ByteDance may try and appease Trump by asserting some type of “deal” after which dragging its ft till an alternate is reached. That might match neatly into Jinping’s playbook.

What I can say is that with every passing day, “the TikTok acquisition” seems much less and fewer like a performed deal.

ProBeat is a column wherein Emil rants about no matter crosses him that week.

Leave a Reply